TL;DR
Get self-care and calm essentials delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Seniors Guide published an advice column by R. Eric Thomas responding to a 54-year-old woman who said strangers criticized her low weight and repeatedly urged her to eat at a cookout. Thomas said she did not owe them details of her medical condition and suggested setting a direct boundary if it happens again.
Seniors Guide published an advice column on October 5 in which writer R. Eric Thomas responded to a 54-year-old woman who said strangers criticized her weight and repeatedly pressed her to eat at a community cookout. The reader attributed her weight loss to a post-surgical medical condition that requires daily IV nutrition; Thomas said she did not owe the strangers her medical history to justify declining more food.
In a letter published by Seniors Guide, the woman said her condition limits how much she can eat and that she had lost considerable weight. She described being glad to attend the cookout, meet neighbors and sample some of the food. She said she had brought a dish and was grateful to feel well enough to socialize.
According to her account, several women she had not met told her she was too skinny and needed to eat more. She said two of them filled a plate and put it in front of her. When she declined, she said they continued commenting on her appearance, including comparing her to a “gangly young boy.” The woman wrote that eating beyond what she could tolerate might make her sick, and that she left before she began to cry.
The reader asked whether she should have explained her medical history. Thomas answered that her polite refusal was sufficient and characterized the women’s behavior as bullying, regardless of what they intended. He suggested that, if the comments happen again, she could say directly that remarks about her body are unwelcome and must stop.
The exchange concerns a common boundary question: whether someone facing health-related changes to their body must disclose private medical information to stop unsolicited comments. Thomas’s response is that the reader could decline food without offering strangers an explanation. That distinction matters here because the woman said she was already aware of her weight and was managing a condition that affected what she could eat.
The account also highlights how repeated pressure can affect participation in community life. The reader said she wanted to become more active as her strength improved, but worried about encountering more body shaming. Thomas urged her not to let the incident keep her away from social gatherings, while recognizing that the strangers’ comments were unacceptable. The column offers advice, not a medical assessment or independent investigation of the incident.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Reader’s Cookout Account
The item appeared in Seniors Guide’s advice section under the title “Skinny from Illness, Shamed by Strangers.” The letter was signed “Skinny and Hungry.” The reader’s description of daily IV nutrition and limited ability to eat comes from her letter; the published material does not identify her or provide medical records.
Thomas is an author and advice columnist. In this response, he focused on the conduct described at the cookout and on the reader’s question about disclosure. He said that even without a medical condition, the women had no right to pressure her to eat or comment on her body. The exchange is presented as an advice column rather than a report based on interviews with other people who attended.
“I feel as though politely declining extra food should have been sufficient and I don’t feel as though I need to disclose my condition to defend myself.”
— The reader, in her letter to Seniors Guide
medical privacy signs for social gatherings
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Details the Column Cannot Verify
The account comes from one reader’s letter, and the column does not include responses from the women or other cookout attendees. It is not clear when the gathering occurred, whether the reader later spoke with anyone involved, or whether she has returned to community events since then. Her condition and treatment are described in her letter but are not independently documented in the published item.
The column also does not provide medical guidance about her nutrition or weight. Its focus is the social interaction and the reader’s question about whether she had to disclose private health information.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Setting Boundaries at Future Events
Thomas’s response leaves the decision about attending future gatherings with the reader, while encouraging her not to let the strangers’ conduct keep her isolated. If anyone makes similar remarks, the wording he suggested gives her an option for ending the conversation without explaining her diagnosis. The column reports no follow-up from the reader, so it is unknown whether she used that approach or received support from neighbors.
personal boundary training for social events
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
What happened at the cookout?
The reader said several women criticized her weight and urged her to eat more, even after she declined. She wrote that she left after the comments continued.
Why did the reader say she had lost weight?
In her letter, she attributed the weight loss to a post-surgical condition that requires daily IV nutrition and limits how much she can eat.
Did Thomas say she needed to disclose her condition?
No. Thomas said she did not owe the women more than her refusal and did not need to share her medical history to defend it.
What did Thomas suggest she say if it happens again?
He suggested telling the people making comments that remarks about her body are unwelcome and that she will not tolerate more of them.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
